The other day a question came to me via e-mail: “Why do some Harley owners hate the Street 500 and Street 750 motorcycles?” Well, hate is a bit of a strong word, but as a Harley owner who dislikes the Street 500 and Street 750, I felt I could give a qualified answer.
SPOILER ALERT: It has nothing to do with liquid cooling or small displacement size.
There are two main reasons (and a few ‘bonus’ reasons) why Harley owners don’t like the Street 500/750. Some of these I agree with, some I don’t.
1) The motor is not a traditional Harley-Davidson motor
Harley-Davidson’s full name is The Harley-Davidson Motor Company. Think about that. The company is named after their motors, not their motorcycles. Over 100 years after it’s founding, Harley-Davidson still places emphasis on its motors, so much so that other manufacturers have intentionally tried to duplicate their sound. The Street 500 and 750 represent a big shift from that traditional push-rod, air cooled, Harley-Davidson motor. It uses no push rods and opts for liquid cooling instead of air cooling. Harley-Davidson motorcycles also tend to be big displacement, low RPM gas hogs. The Street 500 and 750 motorcycles don’t sound like, look like, feel like, or ride like a traditional Harley-Davidson, and that irks some people.
2) The quality is terrible and cheapens the overall Harley brand
Any motorcycle manufacturer could build a budget-friendly entry-level motorcycle. It’s one thing to build that bike, it’s another thing to build it well. One company doing it right is Yamaha with their Yamaha R3, the baby-sibling of their famed R6 supersport. The R3 boasts R6-inspired style, it outperforms the other motorcycles in it’s class (CBR-250, Ninja 300, etc.), and it still offers a level of fit and finish for it’s price-point.
So how does Harley-Davidson’s Street family of motorcycles do compared to the competition? Piss-poor. Whether we’re talking about performance, quality of parts, reliability, or fit and finish, the Street 500 and 750 motorcycles have serious weaknesses to at least some if not all of their major competitors. Take a look at the welding on the frame of a Street 500 or 750, or the way the wires come in to the hand controls. The bike just yells cheaply built like no other Harley-Davidson ever has, since the AMF years… but Harley owners don’t talk about that either.
In the eyes of Harley owners, buying a Harley-Davidson should mean buying a well made product, and if it doesn’t outright beat it’s competition, it should at least outshine and outlast it. The Street does none of these things. That Yamaha R3 on other hand, it’s a pretty spiffy machine!
Other small issues that make some people dislike the Harley-Davidson Street 500 and 750 motorcycles
- Harley-Davidson announced that the Street would be manufactured overseas for sale in foreign markets (India). This meant that the bike would not be made by American workers, who would then ship the bike overseas, but rather would cost Americans their jobs in the eyes of some. Read this story on Harley-Davidson closing down their factory in Kansas City for more on that.
- Even Harley-Davidson’s own dealers don’t want to push the vehicle or speak highly of it because doing so would damage their own credibility. Dealerships and sales people (who rely on their reputation to put bread on the table) just don’t want to be associated with this machine, and that hurts it’s reputation.
- The brakes are weak by modern street bike standards, but, I guess that’s okay, because the performance is even worse.
- The fact Harley-Davidson couldn’t be bothered to put practical usable mirrors on this show the Motor Company’s own cost-cutting disinterest with this bike. It was never built as a point-of-pride for the brand but rather as a necessity dictated by consulting firms and the accounting department.
- Common issues and recall issues (look up Harley Street lag and leap on Google for examples…)
Don’t buy into anyone telling you that the Street is only unloved because it’s liquid cooled, small, inexpensive, and/or dainty. The reality is that Harley-Davidson failed to make a budget-friendly entry-level motorcycle that Harley enthusiasts, sales people, and dealers, could happily embrace and recommend.